One of the most emotionally resonant moments on American Idol 2025 came from 17-year-old Slater Nalley, whose heartfelt original song moved all three judges—Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—to tears.
People.
Slater, a high school student from Tennessee, performed “Traces of You,” a poignant tribute inspired by a poem written by his English teacher, Mrs. Davis, in memory of her late son, Carter Davis, who passed away eight years prior. Slater transformed her words into a song that deeply touched everyone in the room.
Before his performance, Mrs. Davis introduced Slater to the judges, sharing the story behind the song. As Slater sang, the judges were visibly moved. Carrie Underwood, who has experienced personal loss herself, was seen wiping away tears, later expressing that anyone who has lost someone could relate to the song.
The judges unanimously praised Slater’s performance. Luke Bryan commended his authenticity, while Lionel Richie highlighted the emotional depth of his delivery. Carrie Underwood described the performance as a beautiful tribute that honored Carter’s memory.
Slater’s audition not only earned him a golden ticket to Hollywood but also left a lasting impression on viewers and judges alike, showcasing the profound impact of music in expressing and healing from personal loss.
You can watch Slater Nalley’s emotional audition here: